Who Should Win?
ali,kelly,mark, roger300.jpg

Who would you like to see win The Biggest Loser

  • Ali
  • Kelly
  • Mark
  • Roger
Vote Results

Posted by Michelle McIvor on April 10, 2008 12:25 PM

Comments

I have said from the very beginning that the pink team is my first choice. I am happy beyond measure that Ali is in the finale. She is fierce.

I seriously hope that she is competing against Mark, because I think she would have him knocked out.

Posted by: Mrs. F | April 10, 2008 02:57 PM

I think Ali is great and I'm proud of her for doing so well, but I'm one of the ones who don't believe she should have been allowed back after being voted off. For that same reason, I don't think Mark should have been allowed back. That leaves Roger and Kelly. Because of some of the ways that Roger has behaved, I'm voting for Kelly. I can't wait to see what she looks like at the finale.

Posted by: KS | April 10, 2008 06:12 PM

This program is called the Biggest Loser! That so far makes Roger the Biggest loser out of the four remaining contestants he has lost the most weight. So if the are not going to follow the shows title they need to change the name of the program. It should not be up to the public to vote for who stays and who goes. This is totally unfair to Roger and Mark. My vote who have to be that Mark goes home, he should have never been allowed to have returned same as Ali. Roger is the Biggest Loser.

Posted by: CB | April 10, 2008 07:43 PM

I would like to say that everyone is a winner.. I think that they each have come so far and i think that each of them have made some changes and look wonderful.. But I honestly think that kelly should win.. and I believe that because she has worked hard.. and has shown that she has turned her life around.. I can't wait to see how she looks during the show.. I have been watching her for 15 weeks... she looks amazing.. GO KELLY!!!!!!

Posted by: amy | April 10, 2008 07:45 PM

KELLYKELLY KELLY sHE HAS DONE A GREAT JOB.NEVER SENT HOME,OVERCOMING THOSE 3 YOUNG BRATS THAT WERE NOTHING LESS THEN DISRESPECTFUL SNOTS.I BELIEVE THR 3 BRATS SHOULD HAVE BEEN SENT HOME BECAUSE OF THEIR LACK OF GOOD SPORTSMANSHIP.I HAVE NEVER SEEN AS BIG A CRYBABY AS MARK HE IS ALSO AN ARROGANANT JERK.I THINK ROGER SHOULD STAY....

Posted by: JR | April 10, 2008 08:52 PM

I think Ali should win. She's done an amazing job. Roger has been there the whole time like Kelly but they don't deserve to win. They played the game and weren't there to really lose the weight. Mark has been great this season-he's a whole new person. Ali is the biggest loser in my book

Posted by: JM | April 10, 2008 09:06 PM

It's only fair that Roger or Kelly win!! They started the journey from the beginning and have worked hard for it!! They deserve it. Mark and Ali should not win it's not fair!!

Posted by: Melissa | April 10, 2008 09:11 PM

I just read a very good interview with Mark: http://www.dietsinreview.com/diet_column/04/mark-kruger-of-biggest-loser-talks-with-dietsinreview/

I really appreciate how this show has changed him. But I think Ali will win.

It would be great to see Kelly win - it would be such a nice boost to her ego. She looks terrific now and kudos to her. She had Roger on the triathlon right until the stairwell. You ROCK Kelly!

Posted by: Barbara | April 10, 2008 11:04 PM

I personally think Roger has been the Biggest Loser this whole season and I love his attitude, his personality has been the same since day one, he's humble, I admire that about him. Mark and Ali definitely changed when they started looking better and became arrogant and I hope neither of them wins at the finale for that reason! I like Kelly, too but it's a known fact that men have the better metabolism so between the two, I think Roger will pass her by and win this! By the way, Mark & Ali are starting to look wretched like people with eating disorders which no doubt at this point, they have developed-it will take a lot of makeup to make them either look presentable at the finale with the way they looked on Tuesday's episode let alone the possibility of even more weight loss! So, "roll tide" & go Roger!

Posted by: Tonya | April 11, 2008 12:59 AM

I personally think Roger has been the Biggest Loser this whole season and I love his attitude, his personality has been the same since day one, he's humble, I admire that about him. Mark and Ali definitely changed when they started looking better and became arrogant and I hope neither of them wins at the finale for that reason! I like Kelly, too but it's a known fact that men have the better metabolism so between the two, I think Roger will pass her by and win this! By the way, Mark & Ali are starting to look wretched like people with eating disorders which no doubt at this point, they have developed-it will take a lot of makeup to make them either look presentable at the finale with the way they looked on Tuesday's episode let alone the possibility of even more weight loss! So, "roll tide" & go Roger!

Posted by: Tonya | April 11, 2008 12:59 AM

Go, Roger! I can't wait to see what he looks like at the finale! I think him and Kelly have worked hard and I don't think Mark or Kelly should've been allowed to come back, that didn't seem fair! Ali is so smug and thinks her and Mark have it in the bag! Well, I doubt they'd let him pack her over the finish line at the finale and share the money with her so: "Sorry, Ali"! BTW, they are looking really aged-that's what happens when you're older and you lose too much fat too fast, you just look haggard!

Posted by: bug | April 11, 2008 01:07 AM

I used to really admire Jillian as a trainer until the way she favored Ali, did anyone else notice how after she hadn't been allowed to work with Kelly & Ali for a week she was just so excited to see Ali and poor Kelly had to actually wrap her arms around their backs and say, "hey guys, don't forget about me" How sad, Kelly is twice the woman Ali could ever be in character and will be half the woman she was on Tuesday at the finale, she deserves it too since she had a trainer that didn't really do her justice even though Kelly remained so loyal to her beloved "black" team!

Posted by: Billie | April 11, 2008 01:23 AM

AMEN, Billie!

Posted by: KS | April 11, 2008 07:13 AM

I agree with a lot of you.Roger has lost the most, so he's the biggest loser. Ali and Mark SHOULD NOT lose any more weight. If the goal of the show is be healthy, their weight loss is bordering on unhealthy.

I actually think Kelly has a pretty good shot at winning. She's got the most weight left to lose of anybody there. I think her and Roger could easily drop another 20. Of course, this is Kelly's second largest weight loss. That 300 she dropped a few years ago by dumping Paul has probably done more to help her on Biggest Loser than anything. It's no coincidence that she's truly blossomed once she's been away from his smothering presence.

Still, I think all the finalists have done a great job. If I was Mark, I'd want to be eliminated. It's unlikely he can lose enough to get the grand prize, but he'd have a great shot at the 100k.

Posted by: deramojd | April 11, 2008 07:40 AM

I think they have all done a great job. I do not agree with bring back people that have been voted off. Jillian disappointed me with all the favortitism she showed this year. Ali looks like she has lost to much weight if Mark losses much more he will start looking unhealth also. So I think it really should be between Roger and Kelly. Kelly all the way.

Posted by: denise | April 11, 2008 09:36 AM

I really hope Kelly wins! She looks great already, and has been sick since being back, but has pushed thru it and kept working out, and eating right. She has a lot of guts and I am so proud of what she has accomplished.

BTW "deramojd", Kelly has called Paul almost everyday since she's been home to check on him, b/c he's been very ill. She's concerned about him and his well being, and they have remained friends. So, please stop insulting my friends, when u have no idea what you are talking about. Paul is a wonderful, caring man that I am blessed to have as a friend, and he thinks enough of my family to call us his own family. Kelly is a good friend too, and her and Paul have a very amicable relationship for a divorced couple. I hope I have that much integrity. Kelly, you rock, and you're beautiful. I love ya!

Posted by: Lori | April 11, 2008 12:46 PM

I too think ali has lost to much she realyy looks sicks, I think that kelly should win, and that ali and mark should of not be aloud to return. and also i too thought that was fair how jillian acted toward kelly, and gave all her attntion to ali. i do hope that kelly wins i have watched the season from week one and kelly deserves to win

Posted by: char | April 11, 2008 01:20 PM

Kelly is a "Class Act"and hopefully will be the Boggest Loser. Way to go Kelly!!

Posted by: Patty | April 11, 2008 04:09 PM

Kelly is a "Class Act"and hopefully will be the Biggest Loser. Way to go Kelly!!

Posted by: Patty | April 11, 2008 04:09 PM

Kelly is a "Class Act"and hopefully will be the Biggest Loser. Way to go Kelly!!

Posted by: Patty | April 11, 2008 04:09 PM

I think that Ali should be the biggest loser. She looks terrific and has worked her but off even though she was sent home and was able to come back on the show. She is inspriation to me. And that why she should be the biggest loser. Way to go Ali

Posted by: Brenna | April 11, 2008 04:38 PM

Based on percentage of weight loss Ali has actually lost the most weight, and I think that she can become the next biggest loser.

Posted by: LAllen | April 11, 2008 06:44 PM

CB you comment that Roger is the biggest loser, yes in terms of pounds, but in terms of percentage of beginning body weight Ali has lost the most, going by weight alone is unfair. So go Ali! I think Kelly and Roger would be neck and neck for percentage also.

Posted by: Rebecca | April 11, 2008 08:47 PM

I really hope that Kelly wins. I have to admit that she wasn't necessarily my favorite, but she perservered and managed to stay in the game even though her team were clearly waiting for an opportunity to send her home because she wasn't one of the "cool kids." For that alone, I'd like to see her win, but then when you add that it really did seem as if Jillian was just not into her or caring very much about her success (I know Jillian is hell bent on having a woman win, but it's pretty obvious that Kelly would be a distant second choice after Ali) and the fact that despite it all, she's done incredible with her weight loss, I think she deserves it.

Go Kelly!

Posted by: JB | April 11, 2008 11:36 PM

The Pink Team should Win. Never did I hear from the other ladies that they wanted to be the first Woman to win the biggest loser like I heard from Ali. When she came back to the show - the show changed. She brought the competition back to BL and her words where "I want to be the first woman to win the biggest loser". I love Kelly and I hope she is second place - not for the girl power rules but she too has had so many obstacles just like the rest of us. If we could have two winners that would be great.

Posted by: k cross | April 12, 2008 11:09 AM

i hope you win mark you have worked harder then roger:) i love you mark

Posted by: maddison | April 12, 2008 12:55 PM

i hope you win mark you have worked harder then roger:) i love you mark

Posted by: maddison | April 12, 2008 12:55 PM

I would like to see Ali win. I think you have to respect how well she did on her own at home before coming back to the campus. It's a reality show, and the producers will always look for a way to surprise the viewers. Ali and Mark coming back isn't all that different from the "at-home" players coming back a couple of seasons ago. I think all 4 of them look fantastic and are inspiring. Can't wait to see the finale.

Posted by: donna | April 12, 2008 05:50 PM

It appears that the contestants have done something somewhat unethical. Ali's face looked too emaciated from weight loss at the weigh-in, but it was back to being fuller on the limo ride home. Is it possible that the girls and guys popped diuretics in order to lose those last pounds?!!! Kelly could only lose up to 9 pounds prior to the last weigh-in. How could they have "all" lost 12-15 pounds much at this stage of the game when they didn't even have a trainer for the week? They certainly did not starve themselves to that weight? I am calling for an examination of what exactly happened here. While it would great for a woman to win, it is not a win if any of them cheated be them male or female and using diuretics is only temporary weight loss and would cause them to just gain in back the next day or in the days following.

Posted by: Kali Elizabeth Yuga | April 12, 2008 08:01 PM

I hope Kelly wins. She is a true inspiration for women. I love her honesty and the way she has been so genuine with everyone. It is awesome to see a divorced couple get along so greatly too. You rock Kelly and I will be cheering for you.

Posted by: Amy | April 12, 2008 10:07 PM

Roger should be the 3rd finalist. Actually since he has lost the most weight he should be the BIGGEST LOSER!

Posted by: Ginger | April 13, 2008 10:08 AM

i ali win b/c i think a girl should b/c we always had a guy

Posted by: tina | April 13, 2008 03:28 PM

i hope ali wins b/c i think a girl should b/c we always had a guy

Posted by: tina | April 13, 2008 03:29 PM

I THINK KELLY SHOULD WIN SHE'S BEEN THERE FROM THE BEGINING,THE GUY'S WERE ROUGH ON THE WOMAN,BUT LOOK WHO'S CRYING NOW.I'M SO PROUD OF BOTH WOMEN,BUT I'D LIKE TO SEE KELLY WIN,NOTHING AGAINST ALI,SHE'S DONE A WONDERFUL JOB THEY ALL LOOK GOOD THE MEN ARE SUCH CRY BABIES. GO KELLY, YOU GO GIRL......

Posted by: dianne hogan | April 13, 2008 04:02 PM

I THINK KELLY SHOULD WIN SHE'S BEEN THERE FROM THE BEGINING,THE GUY'S WERE ROUGH ON THE WOMAN,BUT LOOK WHO'S CRYING NOW.I'M SO PROUD OF BOTH WOMEN,BUT I'D LIKE TO SEE KELLY WIN,NOTHING AGAINST ALI,SHE'S DONE A WONDERFUL JOB THEY ALL LOOK GOOD THE MEN ARE SUCH CRY BABIES. GO KELLY, YOU GO GIRL......

Posted by: dianne hogan | April 13, 2008 04:02 PM

I think Ali should win because she's been working hard ever since she got back in the game, KEEP IT UP!!!

Posted by: Mary Iliopoulos | April 13, 2008 07:54 PM

I agree that Roger should be in the final three. He should also be the Biggest Loser. He has been an inspiration to many people. To be the the size he was at the beginning of the show andto see how far he has come is truly inspirational. Roger you know that down south it is Auburn or Alabama, So let me tell you this Auburn fan is pulling for you all the way. And will agree with others that Mark has lost too much. He looks unhealthy. But I do hope that the shows Drs. ar monitoring his loss.

Posted by: jackieg | April 13, 2008 08:04 PM

I think Mark and Jay were the biggest cry babies. I have never seen grown men cry as much as they have in my entire life. I'll agree being on the show is probably a bit of an emotional experience but give me a break. I have been over those men for a long time. Get rid of Mark. Ali looks great, but doesn't need to lose any more weight. She's skinny enough. I personally hope that Kelly wins. She has been there from the very beginning and has become such a strong woman throughout this whole process. You can tell she has changed not only on the outside but on the inside as well. She deserves to win. I am cheering for you Kelly.

Posted by: jackie | April 13, 2008 11:20 PM

My vote for the BL winner is KELLY!!
Although I am proud of how much weight Ali has lost, I feel that Kelly should win because she has been there though it all

Posted by: Lynn | April 14, 2008 06:47 AM

I would like Ali to win- she works so hard and should never have been voted off in the first place. However, both she and Mark seem like they are going beyond what should have been their goal- if they lost more weight they won't look healthy.

I agree that it seems as though they all must have done something extreme to lose so much weight in one week. Esp Ali and Mark- at their weights it doesn't seem possilble to have lost that much. Shouldn't that have been addressed by the show? Isn't that going against what this show is about- being healthy? This would be bullemia (sp!) which is also what the extreme exercising can turn into.

I hope I'm wrong- but it was a bit alarming.

Posted by: kk | April 14, 2008 08:55 AM

The name of the show is the biggest loser and the person that loses the most should win, and that is Roger. This is not a popularity contest and that is what it seems to be this year with having America vote. I think Mark looks like he has an eating disorder and can't imagine what he will look like on the last day if he loses anymore weight.

Posted by: shelly | April 14, 2008 09:11 AM

I have heard on thru the rumor mill that some ppl, no names were mentioned, were not taking care of themselves while at home. If true, this may be evident on the finale show tomorrow nite. I would hope tht noone would resort to taking diet pills, or purging to win $250K. I would also hope that the BL show would disqualify anyone if they prove its being done. Doing stuff like that is just as dangerous as over eating. I hope it isn't true.

Posted by: my 2 cents | April 14, 2008 12:13 PM

I think Kelly should win, she has been there since day one and has been truthful and up front with people.

Posted by: tammy young | April 14, 2008 12:55 PM

Good luck to all! I am rooting for Kelly, although I think Ali will win. I hope to see Roger, Ali, and Kelly in the final. I am happy for everyone though. The show has inspired my husband and I to lose a combined total of 60 pounds this season! Thanks, everyone! Good luck!

Posted by: Jilly | April 14, 2008 02:21 PM

I really think that Kelly has and should be the winner. I agree that Jillian showed favouritism to anyone and everyone except Kelly. And that woman for the most part has not had the morale boosters that others have. It should only be fitting that it be between Roger and Kelly, the others were gone and twist or not they should not be in the ring for the title. Kelly has really shown me that age and being female are excuses of why I am overweight and has actually given me hope. Thanks Kelly for being so vulnerable in life.

Posted by: nz | April 14, 2008 02:41 PM

I think it should be between Roger and Kelly, they have been there all the way through. I can't stand Mark in is a cry baby JERK!!!! I like Ali, but her and Mark got to come back and I don't think it is fair for the ones that were they all the way. I just hope that one of the girls win...Please do not let Mark win...If he wins I will just kill over I just don't like him at all. For the other three good luck to you. I am very proud of you all.

Posted by: C.P. | April 14, 2008 04:00 PM

Kelly and Roger should be the only ones in this final as it was totally unfair to bring back Mark & Ali (or anyone for that matter). That said, IMHO, Mark is and has been far too arrogant & cocky for my taste; Ali is hypocritical and smug. And, yes, the favoritism shown to those two has been gagging. Kelly and Roger have been there for the duration doing their utmost to lose weight without much "loving support" from their trainers (as has been shown to Mark and Ali). I'd love to see a woman win but, if Kelly can't do it, hope like hell it's Roger. I literally cannot stand those other two...

Posted by: Emmy Lou | April 14, 2008 05:15 PM

I'm very disheartened with this season. First they bring back 2 that were kicked off; then they pit everyone against the yellow team; now America votes. The favoritism shown by Jillian towards Ali is sickening..Ali IMHO is as phony as a 3 dollar bill. Mark acts like he needs a rubber room..he's literally falling apart. Don't insult our intelligence pretending these people aren't doing colonics and sweat boxes. The true meaning of this show has been lost this season. That being said..since someone has to win, I'd hope to see Kelly or Roger, since they have never been KICKED OFF. Bob has been on Roger's side, but who has been on Kelly's? Certainly not Jillian, that's obvious. So I'd really like Kelly to come in first, Roger second. But don't bet on it people..this show has already been decided...long time ago.

Posted by: Karen | April 14, 2008 06:47 PM

Thru out the entire show Kelly has struggled to stay in the game and has done a great job and never quit or gave up on a challenge even if she did come in last, she fought her way thru. She's remained extremely humbled thru the entire process. Of all the contestants I believe she deserves the title. Many can relate to the struggles she goes thru each week. I think Mark and Ali look great but, they were voted off once already and it was said during their eliminations "MARK YOU ARE NOT THE BIGGEST LOOSER" and “ALI YOU ARE NOT THE BIGGEST LOOSER". So, I don't think there should even be a vote in there for those two. I like Roger and he’s done very well, but my vote will be for Kelly. Best of Luck Kelly hope to see you at the gym.

Patty In Cocoa

Posted by: Bids4U | April 14, 2008 07:56 PM

It should be Roger or Kelly because Mark and Ali were sent home and should not have been brought back. That is not fair to those who have been there all of the time. Hope that The Biggest Loser producers don't pull that again.

Posted by: Bev | April 14, 2008 11:03 PM

It seems the majority of people who have posted here believe Ali and Mark should not still be in it. If they were not, that would have left Jay and Dan still in this thing. Given the troubles that Jay seemed to have keeping his diet together, that would potentially have put Dan in the final with Kelly and Roger. Going by past weigh-in's and the determination that was growing in Dan everyday, IMHO, Dan stood a really good chance to be the Biggest Loser. I think the "producers" of this show have done a disservice to the fans of this show by manipulating the program to get certain people in it to the end. I have lost interest in this show and do not even intend to watch the final. Good luck to everyone, I don't care who wins. This show has lost all appeal.

Posted by: KS | April 15, 2008 07:56 AM

I agree with the above. This is rediculous. This would be like Major League baseball saying, "oh! Wait! We know it is gave 4 of the World Series but we are going to have 4 of the teams that have beaten in the playoffs come back, play a one game against each other and the two winners will now be back in the Series and the winners of the two final games will be World Champs!" Ali and Mark were out of the game, period! The should both had a chance at the $100/k, not allowed back in this. The show is a joke and I am not going to watch the final. I don't care who wins.

Posted by: MS | April 15, 2008 08:01 AM


Iam really voting for Kelly, she has had it bad. She held up the black team, which Jiilian should have been proud, but stood by Ali. I really feel for her. Not saying Ali did a great great job. But Kelly has been there thru thick and thin. Iam really proud of each and everyone of them, it is great, wonderful and beatiful thing and they all look wonderful.

Posted by: toni | April 15, 2008 09:20 AM

Kelly you have improved the most-you stuck with it, sometimes on your own and have risen to all occasions. You are beautiful, smart, funny and should win the whole show. Others have done very well but, none have shown the class and hard work that you have. I am rooting for you!
mommyo

Posted by: mommyo | April 15, 2008 09:53 AM

Kelly you have improved the most-you stuck with it, sometimes on your own and have risen to all occasions. You are beautiful, smart, funny and should win the whole show. Others have done very well but, none have shown the class and hard work that you have. I am rooting for you!
mommyo

Posted by: mommyo | April 15, 2008 09:53 AM

Kelly you have improved the most-you stuck with it, sometimes on your own and have risen to all occasions. You are beautiful, smart, funny and should win the whole show. Others have done very well but, none have shown the class and hard work that you have. I am rooting for you!
mommyo

Posted by: mommyo | April 15, 2008 09:54 AM

I can't believe all the negetivity of some of the posters. This is a game show that has many twists and turns. If people where routing for anyone of those who were voted off and then brought back on, they would be delighted. As for the biggest loser, I was glad to see they changed the format of the show. If it was based soley on weight loss, a man would win every year. It is a medical fact that if you put a man and a woman with the exact weight, the man would win all the time because of their body. A woman has more fat cells that a man. And they lose at a slower rate than a man. Percentage weight made it more fair to all. It is up to the person if he or she wants to work harder with exercise and meals. As far as who I would like to see win, I would like to see Ali win, Kelly seemed to slack alot in her exercising and whined and cried way too much, but not as much as the guys.

Posted by: Nancy | April 15, 2008 12:38 PM

Okay, people! We're all really involved in this and we're all seeming a little upset here.
Please don't be judgmental toward the trainers or the contestants. What is, is and, hopefully, the writers will pay attention to the blogs for the next season.
All on the show have done a fantastic job and no one has behaved perfectly because we're all human.
Kelly cried a lot in the beginning and seemed to have no self confidence but look at her now! Wonderful transformation!
Mark was very aggressive at the beginning and at the bridge challenge waited for Ali and they crossed the line together. So what if a man cries, women do it all the time. I like the new Mark and think his family will be better off with his new found vulnerability.
Roger said he hasn't changed but I think everyone has changed, inside and out. He admitted something very important to Bob - his trust issue. I hope he keeps working on that :)
Last, but not least, Ali. One show you weighed the same as me (155) and then you lost weight and this made me eat better and stop being in denial. Thanks for being an inspiration!
America is better off for the biggest loser program!
Best wishes to the final 4!

Posted by: Amy | April 15, 2008 02:31 PM

Well said Amy. I wish all the contestants the best too.

Posted by: Lori | April 15, 2008 02:58 PM

I am really pulling for Kelly. I hope she wins. I think her main goal has been to loose weight and I think she has acomplished a lot. I have watched her as well as the others from day one and she has shown no remorse whatsoever. Because of her weight I know it has been hard for her, but she kept on pressing forward never giving up and quitting. She looks great and I would give her an A+ for effort, sportsmanship and reliability. I also do not feel that Ali and Mark should have been allowed back into the program. Once you have been sent home you should not be allowed to come back. I feel Kelly and Roger are the only ones that should be eligible to win but I am really pulling for Kelly. I think she deserves it.

Posted by: Evelyn | April 15, 2008 03:30 PM

I don't see all that much negativity here as much as some well-placed resentment. Yes, it's a "game" (albeit a high-priced one) but then shouldn't all play by the same rules of said game? Yet, apparently, the producers didn't think so; that's why we're dealing with the mucho-nutso "I'll Get You!" team of Mark and Ali instead of the less aggressive Jay and Dan who by all rights should still be in the running. Bottom line, people: It's called "fair" which this season's show has not been by any means. Personally, I'm glad it's over. That said, Go Kelly and Roger!!!!!

Posted by: Emmy Lou | April 15, 2008 03:41 PM

So many people have said that Mark & Ali don't deserve to be in the finals because they were voted off, but they (Ali in particular) were voted off because of game play. So many people (including me) aren't happy about how the show has strayed from it's original purpose- to help people lose weight- to merely game strategy. I think it's great that Ali & Mark got to come back because 2 of the people who ACTUALLY lost the most weren't taken out of the running because they were "the biggest threats". Last season it seemed that only the people who weren't "threats" and thus lost the least amount of weight, made it to the finale. At least Ali & Mark got to come back and compete more- after all, they earned it by losing all that weight!

Posted by: Cortni | April 15, 2008 04:29 PM

I hope Kelly wins. She worked hard for it. I can't beleive how the guys acted in this season. They were complete jerks.It was not fair for the girls in the challenges. You know what at the end Kelly will win. She is the fighter.

Posted by: AK | April 15, 2008 04:31 PM

The show this season isn't even worth writing about anymore. It's become an unhealthy competition between 2 people who just want to WIN, no matter how they compromise their health. This IS my last season as a viewer of The Biggest Loser. Roger & Kelly are the Biggest Winners in my book.

Posted by: Karen | April 15, 2008 05:52 PM

GO, Ali and Kelly!!!!!!! They are the most awesome people on the show. Unlike Mark because he is a HUGE crybaby.

Posted by: Kyla | April 15, 2008 07:52 PM

GO KELLY!!! I bought a treadmill last month and my 2 mantras on that blasted thing have been, "Kelly did it...Kelly did it..." and "For my heart and my husband... for my heart and my husband.."
Kelly, I hope you are aware of how your grace, fortitude, and endurance are helping some of us! THANK YOU!! I HOPE YOU WIN.

Posted by: S.J. | April 15, 2008 09:37 PM

Doesn't matter who wins: Kelly is the biggest inspiration!

Posted by: Kim | April 15, 2008 09:57 PM

In the end, the one that deserved to win this was Bernie.

Posted by: RS | April 16, 2008 07:41 AM

Glad Mark didn't win he seemed to be a big baby--

Posted by: JoAnn | April 16, 2008 12:36 PM

Glad Mark didn't win he seemed to be a big baby--

Posted by: JoAnn | April 16, 2008 12:36 PM

Glad Mark didn't win he seemed to be a big baby--

Posted by: JoAnn | April 16, 2008 12:36 PM

Lori-are you the Lori in Florida from the Bernie blog?If so, let's continue the chat here. I can't get to the Bernie blog. To Gayle and Floyd from the Bernie blog, if you want me to stop, the answer is...NOT FOR ALL THE MANICOTTI IN ITALY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Joe | April 16, 2008 05:02 PM

I think Kelly or roger should of won, I think its unfair to get kicked off and then brought back..boo to the producers
I was disappointed in the show this year
How do regular people lose tons of weight in that time frame without all the fancy equip or the trainers???

Posted by: pat | April 16, 2008 10:56 PM

I think they all won. This show is an inspiration to alot of people, me being one of them. Congrats to all the biggest losers; I can't wait until next season!!

Posted by: Angel | April 17, 2008 01:09 AM

I agree with the many others, that bringing eliminated contestants back is not right or fair. I got real tired of the gals whining about how they felt they couldn’t compete with the men because they had so much more to lose, or it was easier for them, or whatever. Doesn’t “percentage of weight loss” cover all the complaints? Also, I thought the goal was to lose weight and change your lifestyle, so why was the “first female to win” such a major issue. Billie’s posting of 4/11 was right on about the favoritism.
I also agree that both Ali and Mark look as though they have an eating disorder now, and Ali, in particular, has become extremely “cocky”. I would like to have seen Kelly win because she was there from the beginning, her perseverance, and because of her caring and giving attitude, but that’s not what the show is about. I bet she’s a wonderful nurse though, and I wish her all the best in taking care of her ruptured disc. Congrats to Bernie, he definitely deserved to win.

Posted by: CW | April 17, 2008 12:28 PM

It always cracks me up when people say, "She (or he) has lost too much weight...they look emaciated" etc. Did you see the MUSCLE on Ali's arms?? You don't get that from being emaciated or starving yourself! You have to feed muscle. I think Ali looks fantastic -- every bit as healthy as Jillian -- and 122 is a very respectable weight. She looks vibrant, and healthier than most Hollywood starlets who DO look emaciated and lack muscle tone. You go, Ali! You look fantastic.

Posted by: Melissa | April 17, 2008 01:50 PM

Hi Joe!!! Yep its me!!!! I have been posting in Paul's blog all last week trying to keep ppl informed of his condition. He's out of the hospital and doing better!! Hope you are doing well. Looks like your girl won. I was SO rooting for Kelly but I am a little biased. Congrats to Ali on being the 1st woman BL!!
Paul's family is making a website for him but its not up yet. IDK about Kelly but I hope she & some of the other contestants make websites other than myspace so we can keep in touch and see how they are from time to time. HINT HINT for all season 5 BL.:):)

Posted by: Lori in FL | April 21, 2008 08:37 AM

Lori...Long time no hear. Since reading Orient Express, I read The A.B.C Murders and am working on Cards on The Table. Anyway, I hope Paul is doing better. He wasn't my favorite, the pink and Bernie were, but I don't want anyone to DIE. I may not be able to stand Roger, Mark, Jay, or Dan, but I sure hope no one dies. ESPECIALLY not Bette-Sue or Ali :)

Posted by: Joe | April 22, 2008 07:10 AM

You are too much Joe. I'm so glad to hear you don't want anyone to die. Bette Sue, Ali and Bernie? Well, let's just say they weren't my faves. LOL! I was hoping that Curtis or Trent were going to win the $100K. All the contestants look better! I am so glad that Lyn and Neil have been losing b/c they seemed to struggle a lot in the beginning. Paul is recovering more and more everyday. He's a great man, and is determined to get the rest of the weight off when his Dr says its okay to start working out again. He's now at 217. He said in a radio interview that he knew Kelly had a better chance than he did at winning. He's very proud of his BL partner and what she accomplished. Kelly told me she never wants to be fat again. So, they are both determined to finish what they started and continue on the road to good health.

Posted by: Lori | April 22, 2008 08:21 AM

HI PEOPLE

Posted by: John | April 22, 2008 06:52 PM

HI PEOPLE

Posted by: John | April 22, 2008 06:52 PM

It's a good thing that Ali won. It was about time for a girl to win. And by the way, why is everyone saying that whatever their favorite contestant did wrong is all right because they edit the show? They still did the said thing, whether eye-rolling (Brittany) or cockiness (Dan). Nobody mentions the editng thing about Ali because Ali didn't do anything bad! And contrary to popular belief, Ali did not take diet pills. Take one glance at her, and you'll know. And Lori, I finished Cards On The Table.

Posted by: Joe | April 25, 2008 04:35 PM

Okay Joe, thanks for that update. LOL You are right about some of the editing. Some ppl did say some things they really should not have. It certainly makes for some entertaining TV. I, for one, will not be watching BL again. I'm a Survivor fan, and that is about the extent of my watching "reality TV" if you can call it that. :) Now isn't that crazy? I will watch survivor but not BL. I know, I know....strange.

Posted by: Lori | May 1, 2008 09:28 AM

I think that it is really unfair to the other contestants that Ali and that other guy got to return to the show. There was a reason they were voted off. It's totally unfair. I cant even watch the show anymore b/c of that. The other people were working so hard to win and then this person who got voted off gets to come back on. What kinda B.S. is that.

Posted by: Kathy | May 2, 2008 02:00 AM

P.S. yes, i do agree with the person who said that Jillian favored Ali when she returned. It should have been Kelly or Roger who should have won. They worked hard.

Posted by: Kathy | May 2, 2008 02:03 AM

It does seem unfair that they brought 2 ppl back, but I cannot say that I was upsset b/c it very well could have been my friend going back on the show. I hoped that it would be, but it didn't work out. So, all's fair in love and war I guess. Jillian did seem to favor Ali and Britt a lot, but that could have been editing so IDK.

Posted by: Lori | May 2, 2008 07:58 AM

i wanted mark to win but ali win. i was still happy and i cant wait til' the next season

Posted by: maddison | May 12, 2008 04:33 PM

i wanted mark to win but ali win. i was still happy and i cant wait til' the next season

Posted by: maddison | May 12, 2008 04:33 PM

Post a comment
Back to Diet & Fitness
  • About this Blog
  • We're the contestants who have been voted off season five of The Biggest Loser, but we're not giving up. Follow us as we continue to try to lose weight and follow a healthy lifestyle at home, plus get our inside scoop on what goes on behind the scenes of the show and what it’s like to lose weight with a buddy.
Recent Entries

 

RSS
Favorite Posts
Links